Dell Inc. (NDAQ:DELL) fell after hours today after it released its
8K filing to the SEC, which announced disappointing earnings and revealed that it is currently involved in an informal SEC investigation into the ways it booked revenue during the past year.
Dell's earnings were cut in half from $0.41/share a year ago to just $0.22/share today, which was below analyst expectations. The company attributed this to "aggressive pricing in a slower market". Perhaps as a consequence, Dells market share did increase by 6% to 19.3% - most of that growth coming from outside of the United States. The company's CEO said the following:
"While we are disappointed with the results for the quarter, we are taking the necessary actions to correct missteps and improve our results for the long term," said Kevin Rollins, Dell chief executive officer. "Key actions include accelerating cost initiatives, increasing investments in service and support, and better pricing management."
Meanwhile, the company also announced an SEC investigation:
"In August 2005, Dell received notice from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that it was conducting an informal investigation of the company. The notice stated that the investigation is not an indication that any violations of law have occurred. The SEC has requested information relating to revenue recognition and other accounting and financial reporting matters for certain past fiscal years, and Dell has been cooperating. In the course of responding to the requests, the company recently discovered information that raises potential issues relating to certain periods prior to fiscal 2006. While the company does not believe that these issues have had or will have any material impact on its financial position or the reported results of operations for the relevant years, the company's audit committee, upon the recommendation of management, has initiated an independent investigation. Management is committed to addressing any questions, concerns or issues the SEC or the audit committee may have."
Note that companies are not required to disclose anything that is not material. As a result, this is the first time we've heard of this SEC investigation dating back to August of 2005. The cause for concern is that the company's internal investigation has "discovered information that raises potential issues relating to certain periods prior to fiscal 2006". Whether or not this will have a material affect on the company has yet to be seen; however, it is something that will be held over Dell's head until resolved.
Currently, Dell is trading at a PE of around 19, which is at a discount to their industry and most of their peers. Provided Dell is able to find itself innocent of any wrong doings with the SEC and recover from its pricing mistakes, it could represent a great buy at these levels.
Related Companies & CompetitorsHewitt-Packard Company (N:HPQ)
Gateway Inc. (N:GTW)