“Sometimes when you mix a fabulous
business with a more mundane one, the market values it as a more
mundane business. And literally just separating the two enables the
market to understand the values.” - Bill Ackman
Many activist shareholders push for spin-offs as a means to unlock
shareholder value. These situations typically arise when the activist
investor believes that one of a company’s business segment could
achieve a higher valuation as an independent company. The primary
targets of such actions are usually conglomorates who own
high-performing business segements that share no synergies with the
rest of the company. For example, maybe a software company wholly owns
a data management company - while the two are related, they may not
share enough synergies to justify ownership.
Activist shareholders like spin-offs because they offer a wide variety of benefits to everyone involved:
- Appropriate Valuation - The spin-off enables the
business segment to achieve an appropriate valuation, which could be
many times higher than their valuation operating under the parent
company.
- Generate Cash - The spin-off provides an
opportunity for the parent company to generate significant cash on the
sale and even unload some of its debt on the new entity.
- Tax Free Distribution - The spin-off enables parent company shareholders to receive “free” shares in the new company in a tax-free distribution.
- Dividends and Buybacks - Many activist
shareholders like to push the parent company to then distribute their
proceeds to shareholders in the form of one-time cash dividends or
share buyback programs.
- Buyout Target - A spin-off reduces a parent
company’s market cap, provides it with large amounts of cash, and helps
get rid of some debt on its balance sheet. Activist investors will
sometimes recommend these transactions to make the parent company a
more attractive buyout target.
And spin-offs can also be an attractive investment opportunity for
another reason too. Typically when spin-offs occur, shares are
distributed automatically to all parent company shareholders -
including mutual funds and other institutional holders. Now, many
mutual funds have to abide by specific investment criteria based on
market cap, revenues, and other metrics. Consequently, some
institutional shareholders may be required to sell their new stock as
soon as the spin-off becomes publicly traded. This windfall of
unjustified selling creates an excellent buying opportunity for the
enterprising investor. In fact, published studies have shown that
spin-offs tend to outperform the overall market by a wide margin during
their first year!
There are several types of spin-offs, including:
- Pure spin-offs are by far the most common in
activist situations. These spin-offs involve the parent company selling
off 100% of their stake in the business segment.
- Carve-outs are instances where the parent company will retain a non-majority portion of the new spin-off.
- Stubs are instances where company’s spin-off a
minority interest in a business segment. Typically this is done to
generate cash without giving up control.
- Tracking stocks are spin-offs that are designed specifically to track the value of their business segments.
All of the information regarding new spin-off issues can be found in
Form 10-12B, which is filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC). Proposals to create spin-offs are often found in 8-K filings
(when proposed by the company) or Schedule 13D filings (when proposed
by activist investors). You can track these filings easily with e-mail
and RSS alerts on SECFilings.com.