Electro Scientific Industries, Inc. (NDAQ:ESIO) shares rose $0.45, or 2.19%, to $21.02 today after 11.6% holder Nierenberg Investment Management filed a
Schedule 13D/A with the SEC that commented on Third Avenue Management's recent proposals along with the company's current actions. The hedge fund said that it was pleased with management's willingness to act on the proposals and was impressed by TAM's suggestion of a combined share repurchase and dividend program. Nierenberg also noted the fact that United Microelectronics Corp. (UMC) recently said that it would use its excess cash to retire 30% of its outstanding shares and pay shareholders a one-time cash dividend - actions similar to those proposed by the two hedge funds.
Nierenberg also offered an extension to TAM's plans:
"As Mr. Jensen's letter points out so powerfully, there are other perfectly acceptable ways to use excess cash to build shareholder value. If, for example, ESIO's Board and advisors were to conclude that the best way to improve ROE were to repurchase shares, we could support that decision with just two conditions. First, we would want the size of the repurchase program to be large enough that it would meaningfully boost both ROE and earnings per share, like we believe UMC's program will. And, second, we would like ESIO to make a continuing commitment to use excess cash flow to repurchase a significant percentage of shares on an ongoing basis. To illustrate the size of programs which could be acceptable to us, we could support a one time repurchase of six million shares, which is over 20% of the outstanding share count, succeeded by a continuing program to repurchase at least one million more shares annually."
Clearly, there are many ways in which the company could utilize its excess cash to benefit shareholders. The most important thing to watch, as Nierenberg pointed out, is the scale on which repurchases or dividends are handled. Many times companies will try and silence concerned shareholders by initiating insignificant share buybacks or small cash dividends, which ultimately do very little to deliver shareholder value. A program like UMC's, however, would significantly reduce the number of outstanding shares and consequently boost the company's EPS significantly. Moreover, the cash dividend would rid the company of its idle cash, which can actually be dangerous to have in some cases. Overall, this is definitely a
stock to watch as management works to craft a meaningful response to these proposals.
Related CompaniesGSI Group, Inc. (GSIG)CyberOptics Corporation (CYBE)Cognex Corporation (CGNX)